dyschromatopsia

Stargardt disease or fundus flavimaculatus is a progressive form of juvenile macular degeneration with considerable clinical and genetic heterogeneity.  It may be considered a syndromal cone-rod dystrophy because of overlapping clinical features such as loss of color vision and photophobia in some patients.  Adding to the confusion is the fact that mutations in at least 4 genes are responsible for similar clinical characteristics.  Due to the lack of diagnostic distinctions and the wide range of nonspecific clinical manifestations, Stargardt disease and fundus flavimaculatus are discussed here as a single entity.

Onset of vision loss is often noted late in the first decade of life usually with rapid progression.  However, some patients are asymptomatic until much later, even into the fifth decade.  There is evidence that patients with an early onset have a worse prognosis compared to those with a later onset.  Nevertheless, large series of patients contain at least 23% with 20/40 or better acuity, about 20% with 20/50 -20/100, 55% have 20/200-20/400, and a small number have vision less than 20/400. 

Some color discrimination is lost and photophobia may be a complaint.  Dark adaptation is prolonged but nightblindness does not usually occur and peripheral visual fields are normal.  The posterior pole characteristically has yellowish pisciform, round, and linear subretinal lipofuscin deposits which often extend to the equator.  These may be present before clinical symptoms are present.  Histopathology reveals accumulations of this material in RPE cells.  Atrophy of the RPE in the same region is often visible as well but these changes may be subtle initially.  Some patients have peripheral pigment clumping which may resemble the bone spicule configuration seen in retinitis pigmentosa.  However, retinal vessel caliber is normal in Stargardt disease.  Extensive macular disease can be associated with temporal pallor of the optic nerve.  The ERG shows reduced photopic responses with normal or near normal scotopic tracings.  Fluorescein angiography often reveals more extensive disease than seen on fundoscopy.  Window defects are common in the macula where the RPE is atrophied.  The flecks may be hypo- or hyperfluorescent.  Over 50% of patients have patches of angiographically dark choroid in the posterior pole which is thought to be secondary to transmission blockage by lipofuscin accumulations in the RPE. 

Visual impairment is often noted under the age of 6 years.  The disease is bilateral and loss of vision procedes slowly, eventually reaching 20/100 to 20/200.  Moderate photophobia and dyschromatopsia are present but nystagmus is absent.  The impact on the visual field seems to be minimal and limited to decreased sensitivity in the central areas.

This form of optic atrophy is clinically heterogeneous similar to others.  It is less common than OPA1 (165500).  Visual acuity ranges from normal to 6/200.  Individuals that carry the mutation usually have some degree of bilateral optic disc pallor and dyschromatopsia even in the presence of 20/20 acuity.  This profile is present in the first decade of life in some patients with most experiencing acute or subacute loss of vision between the ages of 18 and 35 years.  Vision loss is progressive in the majority of patients but unpredictable with some experiencing rapid decline whereas others have only a slow decline.  Age and visual acuity are not strongly correlated but in general older individuals have worse acuity.

Enhanced S-cone syndrome, sometimes called Goldman-Favre syndrome, is a retinal disorder characterized by increased sensitivity to blue light, night blindness from an early age, and decreased vision.  Additional features include an optically empty liquefied vitreous, progressive foveal or peripheral retinoschisis, macular cysts, chorioretinal atrophy and pigmentary retinopathy as well as posterior subcapsular cataract formation.  Hyperopia is a feature, at least in childhood.   Enhanced S-cone syndrome is the only retinal disorder that has a gain of a subtype of photoreceptors, in this case the S-cones (short wave length) that detect blue light. Rod photoreceptors and red and green cone receptors are degenerated to a variable degree. Electroretinography shows an extinct rod photoreceptor response and hypersensitivity to shorter wavelengths.

There is considerable variation in the clinical features of NR2E3 mutations which has led to some confusion in the nosology.  Some cases are called juvenile retinoschisis, others are called retinitis pigmentosa, or clumped pigment retinopathy.  Central acuity ranges from near normal (20/40) in young people to 20/200 or worse especially in older adults.  Visual field constriction likewise varies from patient to patient.  Retinal pigmentary changes and the amount of cystic changes in the macula are somewhat age dependent.